Prices updated
Subscriptions
Cigar of the Month Clubs, Compared
A curated box of hand-picked cigars delivered every month. We track the top clubs and line up what each one costs, how many cigars you get, and the effective price per stick — so you can pick the best value at a glance.
Side-by-side comparison
Privada Cigar Club
| Scrooge Cigar Robusto 20-Count Bundle — MaduroBest value | $50.00 | 20 | $2.50 | per month |
| Scrooge Cigar Robusto 20-Count Bundle — Habano | $50.00 | 20 | $2.50 | per month |
| Scrooge Cigar Robusto 20-Count Bundle — Connecticut | $50.00 | 20 | $2.50 | per month |
| Cafeteria Cigars Toro 20-Count Bundle — Habano | $55.00 | 20 | $2.75 | per month |
| Cafeteria Cigars Toro 20-Count Bundle — Connecticut | $55.00 | 20 | $2.75 | per month |
| Cafeteria Cigars Toro 20-Count Bundle — Maduro | $55.00 | 20 | $2.75 | per month |
| Damaged Cigars — Single | $3.50 | 1 | $3.50 | per month |
| Damaged Cigars — Bundle of 5 | $17.50 | 5 | $3.50 | per month |
| Damaged Cigars — Bundle of 10 | $35.00 | 10 | $3.50 | per month |
| Damaged Cigars — Bundle of 20 | $70.00 | 20 | $3.50 | per month |
| Farm Rolled | $20.00 | 4 | $5.00 | per month |
| The Privada Box | $28.99 | 3 | $9.66 | per month |
| Privada Test Blends | $4.50 | — | — | per month |
| Free Shipping Membership | $8.00 | — | — | per month |
Cigars International
| Double Decker | $34.99 | 8 | $4.37 | per month |
| Original Club | $21.99 | 4 | $5.50 | per month |
Holt's Cigar Co.
| Cigar of the Month Club | $34.95+ $0.00 ship | 5 | $6.99 | per month |
Cigar Month Club
| The Original Premium Cigar Club | $33.95+ $8.00 ship | 5 | $8.39 | per month |
| The Rare Cigar Club | $49.95+ $8.00 ship | 4 | $14.49 | per month |
CigarClub
| CigarClub Explorer - 5 Cigars/mo | $44.99 | 5 | $9.00 | per month |
| CigarClub Explorer - 10 Cigars/mo | $89.99 | 10 | $9.00 | per month |
| CigarClub Explorer - 3 Cigars/mo | $29.99 | 3 | $10.00 | per month |
| CigarClub Customs Subscription — 10-pack | $99.99 | 10 | $10.00 | every 2 months |
| CigarClub Customs Subscription — 5-Pack | $54.99 | 5 | $11.00 | every 2 months |
| CigarClub BLACK Membership — 8 Cigars | $109.00 | 8 | $13.62 | per quarter |
| CigarClub BLACK Membership — 4 Cigars | $59.00 | 4 | $14.75 | per quarter |
Cigars.com
| Cigars of the Month | $49.99 | 5 | $10.00 | per month |
Clubs are grouped by retailer — click a retailer heading to open it, or a column header to sort within each group (retailers reorder to follow it, so the cheapest still leads). Per-cigar price includes shipping where the retailer charges it separately. Some links are affiliate links.