Prices updated
The Cigar Scoreboard
Top-Rated Premium Cigars
One score from two voices — expert critics and thousands of smokers.
Critic-anchored. Nine expert publications scored and normalized to a 0–10 scale, nudged by how smokers rate it.
Top 3 Rated Cigars
Espinosa Cigars
Knuckle Sandwich Maduro
$10.76
per cigar
CigarScore8.3
Classic
8 critics · high confidence
Illusione Cigars
ECCJ
$11.53
per cigar
CigarScore8.3
Classic
5 critics · high confidence
Arturo Fuente Cigars
Don Carlos Eye of the Shark
$27.90
per cigar
CigarScore8.2
Classic
9 critics · high confidence
RoMa Craft Tobac Cigars
Neanderthal
$9.00
per cigar
Padron Cigars
Padrón Family Reserve Maduro
$23.99
per cigar
Davidoff Cigars
Oro Blanco
$600.00
per cigar
Illusione Cigars
Haut 10
$15.35
per cigar
San Cristobal Cigars
Golden Hour
$10.24
per cigar
Caldwell Cigars
Long Live The Queen
$13.20
per cigar
La Palina Cigars
Goldie
$15.00
per cigar
Joya de Nicaragua Cigars
Numero Uno
$13.56
per cigar
Perdomo Cigars
30th Anniversary Maduro
$10.12
per cigar
Davidoff Cigars
Royal Release
$114.00
per cigar
Padron Cigars
Padrón 1964 Anniversary Series Maduro
$9.60
per cigar
Arturo Fuente Cigars
Fuente y Padrón Legends
$177.88
per cigar
Liga Privada Cigars
Único Serie Year of the Rat
$19.25
per cigar
Espinosa Cigars
Knuckle Sandwich Connecticut
$11.12
per cigar
Ashton Cigars
VSG (Virgin Sun Grown)
$10.93
per cigar
Caldwell Cigars
Anastasia
$21.03
per cigar
Padron Cigars
Padrón Family Reserve Natural
$23.22
per cigar
Liga Privada Cigars
Único Serie UF-13
$18.32
per cigar
Joya de Nicaragua Cigars
Cinco Decadas
$17.59
per cigar
Padron Cigars
Padrón 1926 Serie Maduro
$15.66
per cigar
Black Label Trading Co. Cigars
Dreadnought
$10.00
per cigar
AJ Fernandez Cigars
Ramon Allones
$8.22
per cigar
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Cigars
Dunbarton Red Meat Lovers
$12.70
per cigar
Warped Cigars
The Devil's Hands Limitada
$3.30
per cigar
AJ Fernandez Cigars
San Lotano Requiem Connecticut
$5.13
per cigar
Arturo Fuente Cigars
Hemingway Maduro
$9.24
per cigar
Arturo Fuente Cigars
Fuente Fuente OpusX (Original)
$22.49
per cigar
Critic scores sourced from Cigar Aficionado, Halfwheel, Blind Man's Puff, Developing Palates, Cigar Dojo, and Cigar Coop. Customer ratings aggregated from 9 tracked retailers.