Skip to main content

Prices updated

Catalogue
Villiger Cuellar Black Forest6.8CigarScore

CigarScore6.8

Very Good

9 critics · high confidence

Critic
Cigar Aficionado9.29/10
Halfwheel5.36/10
Developing Palates7.86/10
Smokers4.1(116)
Villiger Cigars

Villiger Cigars Cuellar Black Forest

Medium-Full StrengthOrigin: Dominican RepublicWrapper: Brazilian Maduro
Notes:EarthCoffeeVanillaFloralBlack Pepper

Best Price

$5.65per cigar

at Famous Smoke

Price Range

$5.65–$6.25

across 2 sites

Spread

$0.60

10% vs market

7-Day Trend

Stable

The Comparison

All current offers

Prices updated

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

13 of 25

Best Price

Famous Smoke

Code: 100CADDY�

In Stock

$5.65/ cigar

$112.99 for 20$190.00

Villiger Black Forest Robusto

Robusto · 5.00″ × 48 · Brazilian Maduro

4(3)
Buy at Famous Smoke

Famous Smoke

Code: 100CADDY�

In Stock

$5.65/ cigar

$112.99 for 20$190.00

Villiger Black Forest Lonsdale

Lonsdale · 6.00″ × 44 · Brazilian Maduro

Buy at Famous Smoke

Holt's

In Stock

$5.75/ cigar

$114.95 for 20

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Robusto

Robusto · 5.00″ × 48 · Brazilian Maduro

4.1(23)
Buy at Holt's

Famous Smoke

Code: 100CADDY�

In Stock

$5.80/ cigar

$28.99 for 5$47.50

Villiger Black Forest Robusto

Robusto · 5.00″ × 48 · Brazilian Maduro

4(3)
Buy at Famous Smoke

Famous Smoke

Code: 100CADDY�

In Stock

$5.95/ cigar

$118.99 for 20$200.00

Villiger Black Forest Toro Gor

Gordo · 6.00″ × 54 · Brazilian Maduro

4.3(6)
Buy at Famous Smoke

Famous Smoke

Code: 100CADDY�

In Stock

$6.00/ cigar

$29.99 for 5$50.00

Villiger Black Forest Toro Gor

Gordo · 6.00″ × 54 · Brazilian Maduro

4.3(6)
Buy at Famous Smoke

Prices and availability sourced daily from retailer catalogs. We do not sell cigars. Methodology · Affiliate Disclosure

The Ticker

Price history

The Critics

Editorial reviews

19 reviews · top score 95

95pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest

Leaf Enthusiast · Nov 22, 2019

Jon takes another new one from Villiger Cigars for a ride: the Black Forest.

6.00″ × 54

Read full review on Leaf Enthusiast
93pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Churchill

Cigar Aficionado · Jun 1, 2020

Smoking this box-pressed cigar is like biting into almond-studded chocolate. More rich layers of malted milk and toffee are brought together by a toasty foundation that ushers all the flavors into the long finish.

Churchill · 7.00″ × 50 · Medium · Dominican Republic

Read full review on Cigar Aficionado
92pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Toro Gordo

Cigar Coop · May 14, 2020

Late in 2019, Villiger Cigars announced its second blend under the Villiger Cuellar line known as the Villiger Cuellar Black Forest. Cuellar is a brand from Villiger that is produced at Tabacalera Palma in the Dominican Republic under the watchful eye of Jochy Blanco. The Black Forest is the second release under the Cuellar brand, […] Key flavors: Mocha (Espresso/Coffee/Chocolate), Citrus, White Pepper, Cedar, Classic Wood.

Robusto · 5.00″ × 48 · Mild to Medium (1st Half), Medium (2nd Half) · Dominican Republic

Read full review on Cigar Coop
88pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest

Kaplowitz · Dec 5, 2019

A nice representation of its composite tobaccos. The bright tang of Dominican, sultry shy of smooth Mexican, ripe maduro, in that order. Overtones of lemony black pepper, cayenne, dark roast java bean, dark chocolate shavings, black walnut. Heavy & crisp. Undertones are a slowly schvitzing patent leather, skim milk creaminess, anise. Underbelly is compost w/ a red/purple fruit ripeness. Could use a bit more creaminess or more oils from the leather, in order to round out profile a tick. Sits a bi

Toro · 6.00″ × 54 · Tabacalera Palma, Dominican Republic

Read full review on Kaplowitz
84pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Toro Gordo

Halfwheel · Dec 13, 2019 · November 2019

If our reviews consisted of rating cigars after only the cold draw and the first third, the Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Toro Gordo would be in contention for my cigar of the year. For that short time, the profile was rich, aggressive and insanely complex, with apple cinnamon, dried tea leaves and coffee beans on the palate along with some distinct vanilla bean sweetness on the retrohale that pulls everything together. Unfortunately, that first third is by far the best part of the cigar, as after that the profile begins a sharp decline from which it never recovers, highlighted by an increasingly aggressive bitterness on the finish. In addition, while the draw was excellent overall, the burn on each of the three samples had to be touched up multiple times. in the end, while there is quite a bit to like about the Villiger Cuellar Black Forest in the first third, if you stop smoking after that you won’t be missing much.

Toro Gordo · 6.00″ × 54 · Dominican Republic

Read full review on Halfwheel
82pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest

Holt's Staff Reviews · Mar 8, 2024

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest cigars don’t come in the typical blowout bin bundles I’m accustomed to reviewing. These premium smokes are actually packaged in boxes, but don’t get me wrong, they still go for a rock-solid bargain. I’ve already unloaded my unabridged praise of Villiger White Forest cigars in a previous review. Let’s take a walk on the dark side and find out how Villiger Black Forest stacks up in a 6-by-54 Toro Gordo.
Read full review on Holt's Staff Reviews
75pts

VILLIGER CUÉLLAR BLACK FOREST

Comedy Cigars Music · Jul 24, 2022

Wood, earth, and chocolate come through Black Forest’s first few draws. Draw and smoke output are spot on. On the retrohale, wood blends with equal bits of cherry and chocolate. That’s enjoyable.The finish leans towards the dark side, providing dark earth, a splash of coffee, and spice. Dark side. Take it as a Star Wars reference or n

Robusto · 5.00″ × 48

Read full review on Comedy Cigars Music
66pts

Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Toro Gordo

Developing Palates · Jan 13, 2020 · November 2019

The Villiger Cuellar Black Forest Toro Gordo is a fantastic cigar and one of the best I have smoked from Villiger in a while. They really got a great blend out of Tabacalera Palma and what a nice Mexican San Andres offering. This is definitely a maduro I will come back to down the road and one I would highly recommend.

Toro Extra · 6.00″ × 54 · Dominican Republic

Read full review on Developing Palates
pts

Villiger Cuéllar Black Forest Robusto

Cigar Journal · Dec 15, 2020 · Top 25 of 2020: The Complete List (Rank #15)

This dark, box-pressed Robusto presents a touch of pepper combined with gentle sweetness and coffee … almost like Cuban coffee. In addition, the cigar develops notes of earth and spice. It is expressive, robust, and wonderfully balanced.

Robusto · 8 (of 10)Size: 127 x 19 | 5 x 48Released: 2019 · Dom. Rep.Wrapper: MexicoBinder: Dom. Rep.Filler: Dom. Rep.Strength: 8 (of 10)Size: 127 x 19 | 5 x 48Released: 2019

Read full review on Cigar Journal

Brand Lineup

More from Villiger Cigars

All Villiger Cigars deals

Recommendations

Similar Cigars to Compare

More Maduro Cigars
Personalized Cigar Matcher

Looking for your next favorite stick?

Take our 60-second Cigar Recommendation Quiz to match your taste profile, strength preference, and budget with top-rated deals across 21 stores.

Find My Match