5.9CigarScoreCigarScore5.9
Mixed
4 critics · high confidence
E.P. Carrillo Cigars Sumatra
Highlighting Ernesto Perez-Carrillo's legendary affinity for Sumatra leaf, E.P. Carrillo Sumatra is rolled at Tabacalera La Alianza in the Dominican Republic. Cloaked in an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper over a Nicaraguan binder and Dominican-Nicaraguan fillers, this medium-bodied cigar provides an exceptionally harmonious profile of toasted wood, seasoned leather, roasted coffee, nutty accents, and black pepper.
Best Price
at Tobacco Locker
Price Range
$5.80–$11.25
across 5 sites · 3 sizes
Shop Spread
$3.95
41% below priciest · 5.00″×50
7-Day Trend
↑ $1.08
22.9% increase
The Comparison
All current offers
Prices updated
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
19 of 21
Tobacco Locker
In Stock
$116.00 for 20
Core Plus Encantos Natural Cigars
Robusto · 5.00″ × 50 · Ecuadorian Sumatra
Tobacco Locker
In Stock
$155.00 for 20
Core Plus Golosos Natural Cigars
Gordo · 6.00″ × 60 · Ecuadorian Sumatra
Atlantic Cigar
Free shipping· $99+ orderIn Stock
$187.20 for 24$234.00
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Robusto (5x50)
Robusto · 5.00″ × 50 · Ecuadorian Sumatra
Smoke Inn
In Stock
$198.95 for 24$222.00
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Robusto
Robusto · 5.00″ × 50 · Ecuadorian Sumatra
Atlantic Cigar
Free shipping· $99+ orderIn Stock
$201.60 for 24$252.00
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Toro (6x52)
Toro · 6.00″ × 52 · Ecuadorian Sumatra
Cigar Country
In Stock
$209.95 for 24$234.00
EP Carrillo Sumatra Robusto
Robusto · 5.00″ × 50 · Ecuadorian Sumatra
Prices and availability sourced daily from retailer catalogs. We do not sell cigars. Methodology · Affiliate Disclosure
The Ticker
Price history
The Critics
Editorial reviews
7 reviews · top score 90
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Toro
Cigar Journal · Apr 20, 2026 · Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars Of The Year 2025
Toro · 6.00″ × 52 · DOM.REP.
Read full review on Cigar JournalE.P. Carrillo Sumatra Toro
Cigar Aficionado · Dec 1, 2024
Topped with a lopsided cap, this cigar has a jagged burn and decent draw, imparting a leathery smoke, accompanied by notes of dark-roasted coffee, rich wood and nuts before the tobacco finish.
Toro · 6.00″ × 52 · Medium-Full · Dominican Republic
Read full review on Cigar AficionadoE.P. Carrillo Sumatra Robusto
Halfwheel · Aug 28, 2024 · June 2024
The E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Robusto seems mostly complete, though still short of the finish line. While the repeated and consistent combustion issues are what hurt the score the most, I’d appreciate some more consistency. The second cigar—the one whose appears most concerned me—was far and away the best cigar. At that particular cigar’s highest point, it could compete with the best cigars E.P. Carrillo sells. Unfortunately, during most of the three cigars, I was left wanting more of a challenge to the damp earthy flavor, both in terms of intensity and the number of flavors. This seems like a good cigar for a redux review in a year or two.
5.00″ × 50 · Dominican Republic
Read full review on HalfwheelE.P. Carrillo Sumatra Robusto
Developing Palates · Oct 11, 2024 · June 2024
The E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Robusto was a pleasant enough cigar to review, but I didn't find any of the thirds jumping out at me for flavor combinations or complexity. I don't think there's any question that the price point is attractive in 2024, where the average new cigar is pushing over $14. I think there is a long list of other E.P. Carrillo offerings I would reach for before the Sumatra.
Robusto · 5.00″ × 50 · Dominican Republic
Read full review on Developing PalatesBrand Lineup
More from E.P. Carrillo Cigars
Recommendations
Similar Cigars to Compare
8.2ScoreDavidoff Cigars
Oro Blanco
8.1ScoreLa Palina Cigars
Goldie
8.1ScoreAshton Cigars
Samplers & Collections
8.1ScorePerdomo Cigars
Humidified Samplers
Looking for your next favorite stick?
Take our 60-second Cigar Recommendation Quiz to match your taste profile, strength preference, and budget with top-rated deals across 26 stores.
