Skip to main content

Prices updated

Catalogue
Tatuaje Mexican Experiment6.7CigarScore

CigarScore6.7

Good

10 critics · high confidence

Critic
Halfwheel6.07/10
Blind Man's Puff7.14/10
Developing Palates6.43/10
Smokers4.8(4)
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Cigars Mexican Experiment

Pete Johnson's pioneering exploration into Mexican San Andrés wrapper tobacco, the Mexican Experiment (ME) is handcrafted at My Father Cigars S.A. in Estelí, Nicaragua. Dressed in a dark San Andrés Maduro wrapper over hearty Nicaraguan long-fillers, it delivers a rich medium-to-full smoke loaded with bittersweet cocoa, oak, black pepper, dried fruit, and earth.

Best Price

$8.66per cigar

at Cigar Country

Price Range

$8.66–$8.66

across 1 site

Shop Spread

—

One shop at this size

7-Day Trend

—

Stable

The Comparison

All current offers

Prices updated

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

1 of 28

Best Price

Cigar Country

In Stock

$8.66/ cigar

$129.95 for 15$144.84

Tatuaje ME II Toro

Toro · 5.75″ × 50 · Mexican San Andrés

5(1)

Prices and availability sourced daily from retailer catalogs. We do not sell cigars. Methodology · Affiliate Disclosure

Accessories

Pair it with

You'll want something to cut and light it. These are the ones we'd buy.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Ticker

Price history

The Critics

Editorial reviews

19 reviews · top score 94

94pts

Tatuaje Mexican Experiment II Belicoso

The Cigar Authority · Mar 5, 2020

The Mexican Experiment was originally released in 2012 before coming back in to 2019 under the name Mexican Experiment II and it's worth smoking!
Read full review on The Cigar Authority
93pts

Tatuaje ME II Toro

Cigar Dojo · Sep 12, 2019

I ask a lot from the cigars I smoke. I think we all do. We ask for good construction and combustion. We look for a smooth draw with well-packed tobacco. We ask for complexity and balance of flavor. That’s a lot to ask. We’re a bit demanding. Why does this matter? It matters because these are the things we have in our heads before we put flame to tobacco. It matters because we are not easy to please. Okay, I’ll speak for myself. I am not easy to please. On top of that I had very high expectations of this cigar based on my previous experiences. The deck was stacked against the ME II. It was far more likely to disappoint and not meet these lofty expectations, but sometimes we are reminded that, when a blender really knows tobacco, wondrous things can happen! The Tatuaje ME II will probably have a spot in my personal Top 15 Cigars of 2019 list. It may have a spot in the top half of that list—it was THAT good. It was so good that I’ve smoked four more since I took my notes for this review. It has just about everything I ask for from a cigar—at least in its price range, which, at $10, is more than fair, in my opinion.

Toro · Medium-plus · Nicaragua

Read full review on Cigar Dojo
92pts

Tatuaje ME II Toro

Blind Man's Puff · Aug 21, 2020 · August 2019

The original Tatuaje Mexican Experiment was released in 2012. The cigar was described as a concept to try blending a cigar with a Mexican San Andrés wrapper and see what happened. There were a total of five sizes released and each size was exclusive to either a retailer or a region of the country. They came in bundles of 25. Then, in 2019, Tatuaje decided to make a sequel of sorts to the cigar dubbed the ME II, the ME of course standing for Mexican Experiment. It does not go unnoticed that the name resembles the Me Too movement but seems otherwise unrelated. At the same time, the company re-released the original Mexican Experiment in the original bundles and original sizes. This cigar was reviewed blind (no bands) by a panel of at least 4 reviewers. They did not know what they were smoking beforehand. The scores are an average of all the reviewers' scores with outliers removed. All of our cigars reviewed are shipped to the panelists with Boveda packs to ensure optimal smoking experience. It is undisclosed what the difference is between the two blends as both use a Mexican San Andrés wrapper with Nicaraguan binder and filler. The new blend is only released in 4 sizes and this allows Pete Johnson to give them a packing update, whereas the original Mexican Experiment is bound by substantial equivalence to stay the same. Also the re-released of the Mexican Experiment was limited to 1,000 bundles of 15 of each size, while the ME II is a regular production cigar. It is rolled like many other Tatuajes at the My Father Cigars S.A. factory in Nicaragua. All sizes of the ME II come in boxes of 15 and sell for $10. The sizes are: Robusto (5 x 54) – $10, Toro (5 3/4 x 50) – $10, Churchill (6 1/2 x 48) – $10, and Belicoso (5 x 52) – $10.

Toro · 5.75″ × 50 · Medium-Strong · Nicaragua

Read full review on Blind Man's Puff
91pts

Tatuaje ME Robusto (2019)

Cigar Coop · Nov 27, 2019

Agile Cigar Reviews are cigar assessments where we use a lightweight, shorter format. These will never take the place of our comprehensive reviews. They are only used on blends we have previously assessed. This might be a blend we are re-scoring or giving a score for the first time. It might be a blend we […] Key flavors: Mocha (Chocolate, Coffee), Pepper, Earth, Citrus.

Robusto · 5.00″ × 54 · Medium to Full · Nicaragua

Read full review on Cigar Coop
90pts

Tatuaje ME II

Kohnhed · Jun 7, 2022

Wrapper: Mexican San Andrés Binder: Nicaraguan Filler: Nicaraguan Size: 5 x 54 Robusto Box Pressed Strength: Full Price: $10.00 BACKGROUND: The original ME blend was a limited release in 2012. Only…

Robusto Box Pressed · 5.00″ × 54 · Full

Read full review on Kohnhed
90pts

Tatuaje Mexican Experiment II

Leaf Enthusiast · Aug 29, 2019

It took seven years for the sequel, but Tatuaje’s Mexican Experiment II is possibly even better than the original

Toro · 5.75″ × 50

Read full review on Leaf Enthusiast
87pts

Tatuaje Mexican Experiment II Belicoso

CigarsLover Magazine · Jun 9, 2020

The Tatuaje Mexican Experiment II Belicoso is a cigar produced in Nicaragua and the mind behind the brand is that of Pete Johnson. The Mexican Experiment II line is the second release (as expressed with “II”) of a blend that involves the use of Mexican San Andres tobacco. The first Mexican Experiment was released […]

Nicaragua

Read full review on CigarsLover Magazine
87pts

Tatuaje Limited Series Mexican Experiment Robusto

Halfwheel · Jun 10, 2012

The key word in this cigar is experiment , and certainly this is more the result of several experiments as opposed to a one-off trial. The results are good if not stellar, with the Tatuaje Mexican Experiment succeeding in showing off some of the better qualities of the Mexican San Andrés wrapper leaf. Is it the most complex Tatuaje out there? No. Is it the best use of a Mexican San Andrés wrapper? Not in my book, as that honor still resides with the La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor. But is it a tasty cigar worth trying? Yes.

Robusto · Nicaragua

Read full review on Halfwheel
60pts

Tatuaje ME II Robusto

Developing Palates · Mar 2, 2020 · August 2019

The Tatuaje ME II Robusto began well, but once the cocoa left it became fairly average and maintained that level of enjoyment the rest of the way. While I probably won't return to this cigar all that often, I would have no problem coming back to it when I'm in the mood for this style profile on occasion. If you're a fan of Tatuaje and the San Andres blends, you're likely to find something here that you enjoy.

Robusto Extra · 5.00″ × 54 · Nicaragua

Read full review on Developing Palates
—pts

Tatuaje ME II Churchill

Cigar Journal · Dec 15, 2020 · Top 25 of 2020: The Complete List (Rank #8)

A box-pressed Churchill in a sandy Oscuro wrapper with voluptuous spice and a fine mocha aftertaste. It also offers a subtle sweetness, hints of fruity notes, but, above all, a whole garden of herbal aromas.

Churchill · 7 (of 10)Size: 165 x 19.0 | 6 ½ x 48Released: 2019 · NicaraguaWrapper: MexicoBinder: NicaraguaFiller: NicaraguaStrength: 7 (of 10)Size: 165 x 19.0 | 6 ½ x 48Released: 2019

Read full review on Cigar Journal

The Community

Smoker reviews

No smoker reviews yet

Smoked Tatuaje Mexican Experiment? Be the first to review it. Your review helps everyone who's deciding.

Brand Lineup

More from Tatuaje Cigars

All Tatuaje Cigars deals

Recommendations

Similar Cigars to Compare

More Maduro Cigars
Personalized Cigar Matcher

Looking for your next favorite stick?

Take our 60-second Cigar Recommendation Quiz to match your taste profile, strength preference, and budget with top-rated deals across 27 stores.

Find My Match