Prices updated
The Catalogue
Gotham Cigars Deals
One row per cigar line — each carries multiple vitolas. Click in to filter by shape and size and compare side-by-side.
Retailer:Gotham Cigars
30 matching cigars found
Cigar LineVitolasStrengthStoresFrom $/eaStore Gap
6.3
Montecristo Cigars
Volume 1: 100 Days
4.5(24)NaturalCedar, Leather, Earth◆ Compare
2 Vitolas
Natural
Medium
Strength
3 / 3
In Stock
$9.13
per cigar · up to $22.20
53%
below next store
6.8
Cohiba Cigars
Nicaragua
4.5(11,890)Maduro · Natural · RosadoEarth, Oak, Toast◆ Compare
17 Vitolas
Multiple Wrappers
Medium-Full
Strength
22 / 22
In Stock
↑ $2.887d
$5.96
per cigar
52%
below next store
7.0
Aging Room Cigars
Quattro Nicaragua
4.7(9,370)NaturalEarth, Almond, Black PepperValue◆ Compare
13 Vitolas
Natural
Full
Strength
19 / 19
In Stock
$4.70
per cigar
50%
below next store
7.4
Liga Privada Cigars
Único Serie Papas Fritas
4.7(1,138)MaduroDark Chocolate, Espresso, EarthGreat Value◆ Compare
4 Vitolas
Maduro
Full
Strength
17 / 19
In Stock
$3.40
per cigar · up to $7.20
48%
below next store
6.6
Rocky Patel Cigars
Vintage 1992
4.5(6,864)NaturalEarth, Coffee, CocoaValue◆ Compare
21 Vitolas
Natural
Medium
Strength
23 / 23
In Stock
↑ $0.867d
$4.40
per cigar
42%
below next store
6.0
Camacho Cigars
Triple Maduro
4.5(3,428)MaduroBaking Spices, Earth, VanillaValue◆ Compare
7 Vitolas
Maduro
Full
Strength
21 / 22
In Stock
↓ $0.227d
$4.68
per cigar
42%
below next store
6.8
Rocky Patel Cigars
Decade Natural
4.5(18,531)NaturalEarth, Wood, FloralValue◆ Compare
10 Vitolas
Natural
Medium-Full
Strength
22 / 22
In Stock
↓ $3.337d
$4.72
per cigar
41%
below next store
6.5
Drew Estate Cigars
ACID Cigars (Other Blends)
5.0(4,679)Maduro · Natural · RosadoFloral, Botanicals, HerbalValue◆ Compare
13 Vitolas
Multiple Wrappers
Mild-Medium
Strength
6 / 9
In Stock
$3.80
per cigar
41%
below next store
6.7
La Aurora Cigars
1987 Connecticut
4.4(216)NaturalCitrus, Wood, EarthValue◆ Compare
5 Vitolas
Natural
Mild-Medium
Strength
13 / 14
In Stock
↓ $0.467d
$3.24
per cigar
40%
below next store
6.7
H. Upmann Cigars
Connecticut by Grupo de Maestros
4.5(67)NaturalCream, Cedar, AlmondValue◆ Compare
7 Vitolas
Natural
Mild-Medium
Strength
7 / 11
In Stock
↓ $0.257d
$4.95
per cigar
38%
below next store
7.7
Montecristo Cigars
1935 Anniversary Nicaragua
4.7(2,753)NaturalEarth, Coffee, Black Pepper◆ Compare
19 Vitolas
Natural
Full
Strength
22 / 22
In Stock
$7.03
per cigar
35%
below next store
6.8
Macanudo Cigars
Maduro
4.5(7,603)MaduroBlack Pepper, Vanilla, ToastGreat Value◆ Compare
18 Vitolas
Maduro
Mild-Medium
Strength
18 / 18
In Stock
↑ $1.207d
$3.00
per cigar
35%
below next store
7.3
Liga Privada Cigars
T52
4.6(5,577)NaturalCoffee, Earth, Leather◆ Compare
23 Vitolas
Natural
Full
Strength
20 / 22
In Stock
$10.12
per cigar · up to $21.50
35%
below next store
7.8
Rocky Patel Cigars
Fifteenth Anniversary
4.4(1,054)NaturalEarth, Coffee, Nutty◆ Compare
16 Vitolas
Natural
Medium-Full
Strength
16 / 17
In Stock
↑ $0.337d
$5.28
per cigar
34%
below next store
6.3
Romeo y Julieta Cigars
Envy
4.7(48)NaturalEarth, Baking Spices, Coffee◆ Compare
Gordo
Natural
Medium-Full
Strength
3 / 10
In Stock
$8.86
per cigar · up to $15.77
33%
below next store
6.9
CAO Cigars
Zócalo
4.6(154)MaduroEarth, Black Pepper, HickoryValue◆ Compare
5 Vitolas
Maduro
Medium-Full
Strength
10 / 12
In Stock
$4.50
per cigar
33%
below next store
7.0
AVO Cigars
Syncro Nicaragua
4.3(2,715)NaturalEarth, Coffee, Leather◆ Compare
6 Vitolas
Natural
Medium-Full
Strength
19 / 21
In Stock
↓ $2.937d
$6.10
per cigar
32%
below next store
6.6
Gurkha Cigars
Ghost
4.5(724)MaduroEarth, Wood, HickoryValue◆ Compare
10 Vitolas
Maduro
Medium-Full
Strength
15 / 17
In Stock
↑ $0.657d
$4.25
per cigar
32%
below next store
7.3
Drew Estate Cigars
ACID Deep Dish
4.9(5,037)Claro · NaturalFloral, Sweet Spice, HoneyValue◆ Compare
Gordo
Multiple Wrappers
Medium
Strength
16 / 17
In Stock
↓ $2.317d
$4.86
per cigar
32%
below next store
6.5
Rocky Patel Cigars
The Edge Maduro
4.5(9,177)MaduroBlack Pepper, Cedar, Baking SpicesValue◆ Compare
16 Vitolas
Maduro
Medium-Full
Strength
21 / 22
In Stock
↓ $0.267d
$3.90
per cigar
32%
below next store
6.4
AVO Cigars
XO
4.5(3,163)NaturalCream, Floral, Cedar◆ Compare
8 Vitolas
Natural
Mild-Medium
Strength
21 / 21
In Stock
↓ $2.927d
$6.39
per cigar
31%
below next store
7.6
Perdomo Cigars
20th Anniversary Sun Grown
4.7(2,006)NaturalCedar, Leather, Nutty◆ Compare
7 Vitolas
Sun Grown
Medium-Full To Full
Strength
23 / 24
In Stock
$6.25
per cigar · up to $14.19
31%
below next store
6.9
Perdomo Cigars
Lot 23 Connecticut
4.6(4,244)NaturalLeather, Baking Spices, Cedar◆ Compare
12 Vitolas
Connecticut
Medium
Strength
21 / 21
In Stock
$5.00
per cigar · up to $10.50
30%
below next store
6.9
Gurkha Cigars
Cellar Reserve 12 Year Platinum Edition
4.5(144)MaduroEarth, Black Pepper, Red PepperValue◆ Compare
13 Vitolas
Maduro
Medium-Full
Strength
13 / 14
In Stock
$4.29
per cigar
29%
below next store
6.3
CAO Cigars
Colombia
4.5(3,131)RosadoNutty, Wood, FloralValue◆ Compare
15 Vitolas
Rosado
Mild-Medium
Strength
15 / 15
In Stock
$4.81
per cigar
28%
below next store
6.5
Drew Estate Cigars
ACID Toast
4.9(4,972)Claro · Maduro · NaturalToasted Wood, Black Cherry, Dark Chocolate◆ Compare
Toro
Multiple Wrappers
Medium-Full
Strength
15 / 17
In Stock
↓ $1.777d
$5.00
per cigar
28%
below next store
8.0
Padron Cigars
Padrón 1964 Anniversary Series Maduro
4.9(18,193)MaduroCocoa, Nutty, Coffee◆ Compare
28 Vitolas
Maduro
Medium-Full
Strength
22 / 23
In Stock
$9.60
per cigar
26%
below next store
6.1
Drew Estate Cigars
ACID Kuba Kuba
4.9(16,816)Candela · Claro · Maduro · NaturalFloral, Herbal, Sweet Spice◆ Compare
3 Vitolas
Multiple Wrappers
Mild-Medium
Strength
17 / 19
In Stock
↓ $1.667d
$5.00
per cigar
25%
below next store
6.0
Rocky Patel Cigars
Cargo
4.0(7,359)ClaroCream, Cedar, AlmondValue◆ Compare
5 Vitolas
Claro
Medium
Strength
4 / 4
In Stock
↑ $0.507d
$2.00
per cigar · up to $3.15
25%
below next store
5.6
Macanudo Cigars
Cafe
4.5(137,587)NaturalCream, Cedar, ToastValue◆ Compare
48 Vitolas
Natural
Mild
Strength
22 / 22
In Stock
$3.60
per cigar
24%
below next store
Page 1 · Showing 1–30